Knowledge base · Costs and rights

What are my rights if a garage repair goes wrong?

By the Spanner and Jack teamChecked

A garage repair is a service, and under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 it must be carried out with reasonable care and skill. If it wasn't, you have the right to ask the garage to put it right (redo the work) at no cost to you, and if that isn't possible or isn't done properly within a reasonable time, to a price reduction, which can mean a partial refund.

What the law says

  • Section 49: every contract to supply a service includes a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill (legislation.gov.uk, s.49).
  • Section 55, right to repeat performance: you can require the trader to perform the service again so it conforms with the contract. The trader must do it within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to you, and must bear the necessary costs, including labour and materials (legislation.gov.uk, s.55).
  • Section 56, right to price reduction: available if repeat performance is impossible, or the trader fails to do it within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. Any refund must be given within 14 days of the trader agreeing you're entitled to it (legislation.gov.uk, s.56).

What Citizens Advice suggests

Citizens Advice (advice for England) recommends:

  1. Talk to the garage first, in person or by phone, then put it in writing or email so you have a record.
  2. Ask them to fix faults that weren't repaired properly, weren't correctly found, or didn't exist before the car went in.
  3. Get a second opinion or written quote from another garage to support your case.
  4. Pay "under protest" if you need the car back during a dispute: write those words on the garage's copy of the paperwork. Citizens Advice says the garage can keep the car while the bill is disputed but isn't allowed to sell it.
  5. Use a trade association such as The Motor Ombudsman if the garage is a member, or an alternative dispute resolution scheme.

Citizens Advice also notes that if you agreed a quote you'll generally have to pay it, while with only an estimate the garage can charge more within reason. You may be able to use chargeback, or a section 75 claim if you paid by credit card and the repair cost more than £100.

Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own Citizens Advice pages. This is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

On this site